Precious Metals Sector Poised For Correction
While gold futures ended the week near $1290, barely $1 off its highs and up ~2.5% for the week, the gold miners told a slightly different story. The GDXJ fell 3.52% on Thursday and only managed to gain 38 basis points on the week despite gold rallying more than $30/oz:
GDXJ’s performance was remarkable, in an undesirable way; against a macro backdrop that couldn’t be much more favorable for the gold sector this was an epic level of futility. Investors in gold mining shares are largely looking for upside leverage to the gold price, full well knowing that they could get stung badly by a big drop in the gold price. Just please give me big upside returns when i’m right about the direction of gold.
So what gives? Why has GDXJ been such a poor vehicle to capture gold upside in recent weeks? The answer is likely multi-faceted and I will take a stab at it here:
- Due to significant fund inflows GDXJ has ‘outgrown its sector’ which has forced it to take positions in many stocks which aren’t purely gold focused, there’s quite a bit of silver in there with a sprinkle of copper. Moreover, there are all different tiers of companies in GDXJ ranging from sizable mid-tier producers (AGI, BTG, IAG, etc.) to exploration stage juniors.
- Despite its relatively disappointing performance GDXJ was still a big winner last year and it’s up more than 16% year-to-date which makes it a good target for tax selling to raise money to pay the tax man – some of this week’s underperformance could be blamed on tax related selling. This kind of ‘uneconomic’ selling activity should in theory offer opportunity to arbitrage the performance gap.
- The leveraged 3x version of GDXJ, JNUG, has temporarily suspended creation orders which means the fund can’t get any larger. This announcement came after the close Thursday, and given that JNUG certainly influences price action in GDXJ some market participants may have ‘traded ahead’ of this announcement.
- Certainly some of gold’s recent bid has resulted from the fear of war or a confrontation of some sort in North Korea or Syria. If we think about such a scenario in logical terms, while precious metals may perform very well against a backdrop of war mining companies may not perform nearly as well given their geographically diverse operations. Moreover, something which we saw in late-2008 was panic selling which had little do with the actual economic value which stocks offered; even though gold mining shares do offer some level of optionality on the gold price they are still stocks after all, and they can trade for uneconomic reasons for longer than we might think (as we witnessed in 2008/2009).
Since its inception there are 20 instances in which GDXJ fell by 3% or more on the same day in which GLD ended in the green:
The short term results are actually fairly positive with an average 5-day return of 2.03% for GDXJ. However, looking out to 20 days the results are decidedly negative with an average loss of 2.37% as well as a couple of significant drawdowns of 20%+.
After being a devout precious metals bull for the last six weeks (I say devout because it hasn’t been easy) and for the vast majority of the last year and a half, a couple of additional factors have me turning mildly bearish on the precious metals sector this weekend:
- The DSI (Daily Sentiment Index) for gold reached 90 at the end of last week – a level which indicates sentiment has gotten a bit overheated.
- A significant layer of support/resistance exists just overhead, combined with RSI in ‘overbought’ territory and overheated sentiment we have a textbook recipe for a pullback/consolidation:
Gold (Daily – 15 months)
- Gold is entering its worst 3-month stretch of the year historically
- May is by far the worst month of the year for GDXJ
This post isn’t intended to motivate my dear readers to liquidate all of their mining share holdings and go long DUST on Monday morning. However, some caution is in order and a paring back of risk exposure to the sector is prudent. For example if I had 70% net long exposure to the precious metals sector at Thursday’s close I would look to reduce it to 20%-30% early next week. For short term traders who are nimble and have a disciplined risk management approach a tactical short in GDX or GDXJ could be in order Monday depending upon how things shake out this weekend.
To find out how I am trading equities, ETFs, precious metals, and junior mining shares in real time including participating in subscriber conference calls and daily morning market emails subscribe to the Trading Lab today!
DISCLAIMER: The work included in this article is based on current events, technical charts, and the author’s opinions. It may contain errors, and you shouldn’t make any investment decision based solely on what you read here. This publication contains forward-looking statements, including but not limited to comments regarding predictions and projections. Forward-looking statements address future events and conditions and therefore involve inherent risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ materially from those currently anticipated in such statements. The views expressed in this publication and on the EnergyandGold website do not necessarily reflect the views of Energy and Gold Publishing LTD, publisher of EnergyandGold.com. This publication is provided for informational and entertainment purposes only and is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Always thoroughly do your own due diligence and talk to a licensed investment adviser prior to making any investment decisions. Junior resource companies can easily lose 100% of their value so read company profiles on www.SEDAR.com for important risk disclosures. It’s your money and your responsibility.